Komputer Numerically Kontrolled (KNK) Router

For discussions related to designing and making ski/snowboard-building equipment, such as presses, core profilers, edge benders, etc.

Moderators: Head Monkey, kelvin, bigKam, skidesmond, chrismp

User avatar
bigKam
Site Admin
Posts: 538
Joined: Tue Feb 01, 2005 5:15 pm
Location: Park City, Utah
Contact:

Komputer Numerically Kontrolled (KNK) Router

Post by bigKam »

DONE!

I worked 62.5 hours straight without sleep --- milling, lathing, drilling, welding, gluing, bolting, and writing custom software for my new custom-built CNC machine. It weighs 2000 lbs, runs at a max. linear speed of 18.23 ft./sec, consumes 6000 W of power, positions with +/- 10^-6 inch accuracy over 12 ft., eats live chickens, and is day-glow orange in color.

OK, so I'm kidding. Made you read, though.

The truth is I am actually going to build a machine. Whether it eats live chickens will depend on what parts I pull together.

I have decided to document my little adventure, with the hopes of sharing as much information as possible. My diary may do any one of the following: inspire, motivate, or discourage. Hopefully at the very least the common denominator will be that the information will make an impact.

To be honest I haven't put much thought into this project yet. A while back, a friend of a friend donated parts to an old ShopBot to Kelvin and I. Kelvin put some work into it and created the SB CNC machine which some of you have seen. It works beautifully. Now I want my own.

At this point, there's no set design or 'plan' that I'm following. It's going to develop as it goes, so it will be interesting.

Let's get started.

Last weekend I visited my family and cousin Kam (littleKam) in So. California. While at my brother Pat's house, I picked up four Ametek servomotors. Last year Pat converted a standard manual milling machine into a CNC machine and he had some motors laying around not in use. I was glad to take them off his hands, and here they are:
Image

They are Ametek 965922-101 servomotors, rated at 12 amps (peak), nominal 38 VDC, and I think capable of delivering a whopping 600 oz-inches of torque. The 5/8" diameter output shaft seems to suggest that they can deliver some umph! Each motor weighs a fair amount, too. On the bottom of the motor is an optical encoder. I don't know the counts/revolution, but will figure it out at some point.

Some CNC's use stepper motors, DC motors that are designed to move in steps, for example, 200 steps per 360-degrees. Steppers are easy to work with and can be operated without a sensor feeding back information about what position the shaft is in. In this case, the motor can be run in open-loop. Steppers are controlled by applying pulses to step the motor from on position to the next. It's a simple setup and great for CNC-type machines where a tool has to be positioning relative to a workpiece in 3D.

Other CNC's use servomotors, a motor with a sensor attached to the motor's shaft. A controller is needed to sense the shaft's position and then adjust the input voltage/current appropriately to control the (angular) position of the shaft. These motor/sensor/controller systems are a bit more complicated, and if the sensor was to ever fail with the controller active, the motor can spin out of control to infinity and beyond. Of course there are ways to minimize this, but in general they are slightly more complicated.

There are advantages and disadvantages of using either steppers or servos. Everybody seems to have their own opinion, so I'm not going to contribute to the debate. However, I've been intrigued by servos and have built similar setups at my day job, so I figured since the motors were free I'd make the best of them. As for the controller and power supply, it depends on my budget and avaiable time, but I'll try to build as much from scratch as possible without nuking myself --- bzzz, bzzzz... I always keep in mind that electricity is extremely dangerous and always double, triple check my connections before turning on power. It doesn't take much current to stop one's heart!

Anyway, in addition to the motors, I also picked up some modular aluminum framing to create the skeleton of the CNC machine. I haven't decided on the size of the machine yet. For now I'm just collecting parts and dreaming.

I will do my best to update this thread as I go and hope that it materializes into something worthwhile. Feel free to ask or inquire about anything or better yet, make suggestions and point me in the right direction. Until next time.
Last edited by bigKam on Tue Mar 31, 2009 12:20 am, edited 2 times in total.
G-man
Posts: 600
Joined: Sat Mar 25, 2006 3:58 pm
Location: northern sierra nevada

Post by G-man »

bigKam,

He,he... I actually believed every word of that first paragraph when I read it... till I got to the "eats live chickens" part.

This is certain to be a really exciting venture. How large of a power supply are you considering in terms of DC voltage out and amp rating? Do you have a preference for linear vs. regulated? I have a lot of parts sources filed away for reference.

While you're in the dream stage, here's something to consider regarding your linear drive system. Most long table systems use rack and pinion drives because ACME screws or ball screws tend to whip and cause resonance problems when the screw length gets much over 4 or 5 feet. One mitigation to the whipping problem associated with a long lead screw is to use a relatively large diameter screw, which has the down-side of being a huge inertia sink when changing directions of travel. I'm assuming (duh) that you're going to want a long table system so that you can cut ski parts. I worked out a very simple drive system that uses a 104" long ACME lead screw (1/2 inch diameter... nice and light) that doesn't whip at speed (and has zero backlash). The drive screw cost about $60 vs. many hundreds of dollars for a rack and pinion system (or thousands for a large diameter ball screw). So, if you're interested, I'll share that drive screw design with you.

Nice summer project.

G-man
User avatar
bigKam
Site Admin
Posts: 538
Joined: Tue Feb 01, 2005 5:15 pm
Location: Park City, Utah
Contact:

Post by bigKam »

Hey G-man,

Do you mean switch-mode vs. linear regulated? I'm not sure yet since I haven't sat down to crunch the numbers in terms of the amount of power I need. I've built several switch-mode and linear power supplies before, but not at the power levels that I'll need for the CNC. I will talk to you about the parts, though.

I'm very interested in your $60 setup. Wow, sounds like a sweet deal. I have been looking at purchasing a long drive screw, but did not consider the resonance issue. This is interesting. Let's chat more about this...

Boy, this is so much fun...
G-man
Posts: 600
Joined: Sat Mar 25, 2006 3:58 pm
Location: northern sierra nevada

Post by G-man »

Yes, that is actually what I meant. On the CNC forums, we most often use the term 'regulated' when talking about regulated switching supplies, and use 'linear' when talking about linear unregulated supplies (admittedly not correct... we've gotten a bit lazy in our use of terms). Most of the folks on the hobbycnc.com forum site are using unregulated linear power supplies. Not many builders add the regulating circuitry to their unregulated linear supplies, for some reason. As you know, it's pretty easy to add. My supply is an unregulated linear supply that puts out 36v DC, rated at 10 amps. My driver board chips can handle up to 42v, but, I only feed the board the usual 36v in case I get any supply grid voltage spikes. It's a very simple supply design, which is probably why it is as popular as it is... heavy, though. One of the main reasons I like the unregulated linear supply is it's simplicity. If it goes bad, I just have to troubleshoot 3 parts, replace the bad one, and I'm back in business. One of the best deals I've seen on regulated switch mode supplies is located here:
http://www.mpja.com/prodinfo.asp?number=17429+PS
I don't know if that's enough juice for your application, but it's sure a good deal. A while back, they had 36v/12.5 amp supplies for 25 bucks. I sure wish I'd picked up a few of those.

I'm sure that resonance is a bigger deal when using stepper motors, than with servo motors, because the resonance causes the steppers to lose steps, ruining the cut. I tried to run my lead screw without my adaptation, and it wobbled wildly (like 2 to 3 inches out of center) at very low rpm (driven with a drill motor rather than a stepper). That kind of wobble wouldn't cut it, no matter what kind of motor was used.

Yes, this is indeed a lot of fun and I'm betting we'll be talking a bunch..

G-man
User avatar
bigKam
Site Admin
Posts: 538
Joined: Tue Feb 01, 2005 5:15 pm
Location: Park City, Utah
Contact:

Post by bigKam »

I set this project aside because of traveling (work and personal), but managed to do some modeling and conceptual design. I'm in the process of securing a workshop (and new home) outside of Reno, so it won't be until late Sept. before I get my hands dirty... but wait'll you see the new bat cave :)
User avatar
RoboGeek
Posts: 239
Joined: Wed Jan 17, 2007 12:08 pm
Location: Middle of a cornfield...

Post by RoboGeek »

I worked briefly for a company that converted machines over - they built them for a place in Corona,Ca that built airplane actuators for trim tabs. I soldered the boards together while another hooked up hardware.

It really worked well and it looks like your on the same track

My bat cave is still full of computers :?
I used to be a lifeguard, but some blue kid got me fired.
User avatar
bigKam
Site Admin
Posts: 538
Joined: Tue Feb 01, 2005 5:15 pm
Location: Park City, Utah
Contact:

Post by bigKam »

I set this project aside back in July, but picked it back up in early December. Made good progress, but the slowest part is waiting for parts to arrive in the mail. Here's what I envision it will look like:
Image

Here's a sneak peek at an x (long) axis rail -- the rails will be mounted to the vertical plane of the aluminum structure:
Image

Several parts I farmed out to my brother for him to make since he has a CNC mill in his garage. He built the mill several years ago and loves to make parts. The rest of the parts I will do my best with tools I have on hand. The more complicated work such as machining the ball screws I handed over to a local machine shop. It's not trivial turning down a 100-inch long screw. As for the electronics, I'm using Gecko servo motor drivers, but built the power supply from discrete components.

The router will have over 85" of travel along x; 45" along y; and roughly 5" in z. Based on my calculations, the gantry should be able to run at 200 inches-per-minute before any whipping will occur. This number is somewhat conservative. I will follow up with more details, so stay tuned....
Buuk
Posts: 150
Joined: Wed Apr 26, 2006 2:49 am
Location: The Netherlands

Post by Buuk »

Sweet! Nice work!
Make things as simple as possible, but not too simple
User avatar
bigKam
Site Admin
Posts: 538
Joined: Tue Feb 01, 2005 5:15 pm
Location: Park City, Utah
Contact:

Post by bigKam »

Put a few more hours into this project after work tonight. Assembled part of the gantry (y-axis and z-axis). Used a hand drill to test the travel of the z-axis -- got 4.75" of travel. Not bad. Y travel is more than 41". Overall, these two axes feel stiff, just what I wanted. My brother Pat machined some of the components for the z-axis and he did a great job.

Here's a quick video of the z-axis in motion and sliding along y [click here (4MB)].

Some photos:
Image

More to come...
Three31
Posts: 70
Joined: Wed Oct 10, 2007 3:20 pm
Location: North Tahoe

Post by Three31 »

Lust...
Brian
User avatar
Head Monkey
Posts: 310
Joined: Sun Jul 17, 2005 4:53 pm
Location: Carnation, WA
Contact:

Post by Head Monkey »

Very nice work man.
Everything I know about snowboard building, almost: MonkeyWiki, a guide to snowboard construction
Free open source ski and snowboard CADCAM: MonkeyCAM, snoCAD-X
User avatar
bigKam
Site Admin
Posts: 538
Joined: Tue Feb 01, 2005 5:15 pm
Location: Park City, Utah
Contact:

Post by bigKam »

After a long day at work, I relaxed by tinkering for about an hour tonight in the bat cave. Tested the x-axis; gantry can jog at 192"/min, 8 inches shy of my original prediction. Close enough for government work.
User avatar
shopvac
Posts: 160
Joined: Sun Oct 12, 2008 2:23 pm
Location: Colorado

Post by shopvac »

I bet your wallet says "Bad Motherf&%*er" on it!
corvettecrazy
Posts: 10
Joined: Wed Mar 11, 2009 6:34 pm
Location: Eastern US

Post by corvettecrazy »

Looks awesome!

You should be able to do a lot of creative stuff on that.

The high school I went to had(still has) a CNC router and we did so many cool projects on it. I am actually going back because they agreed to CNC a bottom mold for me. :D
User avatar
bigKam
Site Admin
Posts: 538
Joined: Tue Feb 01, 2005 5:15 pm
Location: Park City, Utah
Contact:

Post by bigKam »

This is one of the first things made -- it works! I will post more photos and additional details, but simply put, it runs like a charm! Time to make some skis.

Image
Post Reply