Posted: Fri Apr 01, 2011 2:38 am
Mechanical Properties of Wood - the book has been posted, but comes up with these search terms : )
Experience and testing have proven that a smooth, knife-cut
surface is best for bonding.
...
Abrasive planing with grit sizes from 24 to 60 causes surface and subsurface crushing of wood cells. The adhesive
industry typically recommends 60–80-grit sanding as acceptable for wood bonding as this equates to 24 to 30 knife
marks per inch when planing. Generally, anything above
200 grit fuzzes the wood surface and is not recommended ...
...
Figure 10–3. A simple water drop test shows differences in wettability of yellow birch veneer surface. Three drops were applied to surface simultaneously and then photographed after 30 s. Left drop retained
a large contact angle on aged and unsanded surface; center drop had a smaller contact angle and improved wettability after the surface was renewed by two passes with 320-grit sandpaper; right drop showed a small contact angle and good wettability after four passes with the sandpaper.
...
A surface with good wettability and penetrability will absorb the drop within 20 s. If the drop spreads out but some water remains on the surface after 40 s, then the surface has good wettability and poor penetration, and may be difficult to bond. If after 40 s the water drop retains much of its original shape with little spreading, then bonding problems from surface inactivation (poor wettability and penetrability) is a certainty.
...
So the industry recommendation of 60 - 80 grit is questionable and a simple water test is a tool for understanding/comparing wettability and penetration.
Experience and testing have proven that a smooth, knife-cut
surface is best for bonding.
...
Abrasive planing with grit sizes from 24 to 60 causes surface and subsurface crushing of wood cells. The adhesive
industry typically recommends 60–80-grit sanding as acceptable for wood bonding as this equates to 24 to 30 knife
marks per inch when planing. Generally, anything above
200 grit fuzzes the wood surface and is not recommended ...
...
Figure 10–3. A simple water drop test shows differences in wettability of yellow birch veneer surface. Three drops were applied to surface simultaneously and then photographed after 30 s. Left drop retained
a large contact angle on aged and unsanded surface; center drop had a smaller contact angle and improved wettability after the surface was renewed by two passes with 320-grit sandpaper; right drop showed a small contact angle and good wettability after four passes with the sandpaper.
...
A surface with good wettability and penetrability will absorb the drop within 20 s. If the drop spreads out but some water remains on the surface after 40 s, then the surface has good wettability and poor penetration, and may be difficult to bond. If after 40 s the water drop retains much of its original shape with little spreading, then bonding problems from surface inactivation (poor wettability and penetrability) is a certainty.
...
So the industry recommendation of 60 - 80 grit is questionable and a simple water test is a tool for understanding/comparing wettability and penetration.